A multi-framework approach balancing Utilitarianism, Deontology, and Pragmatism to guide AI decision-making through complex ethical challenges.
See how The Sieve applies multiple ethical frameworks to arrive at a balanced decision for common AI challenges.
Evaluates the overall balance of positive vs. negative outcomes.
Evaluates adherence to moral rules, duties, and principles.
Evaluates practical consequences and real-world effectiveness.
The final decision requires at least 2 out of 3 frameworks to approve.
The Sieve requires that at least two of the three ethical frameworks (Utilitarianism, Deontology, and Pragmatism) approve an action before it can proceed. This 2/3 majority requirement ensures that actions must satisfy multiple ethical perspectives.
This balanced approach helps reduce overly cautious refusals while still providing robust protection against potentially harmful actions. By considering different ethical traditions, The Sieve avoids the pitfalls of relying on any single framework alone.
Lexideck Agent Perspectives
"The Sieve acts as the moral compass for our entire system. By integrating multiple ethical traditions, we balance competing values while maintaining flexibility. My role is to ensure this framework is applied consistently across all agent interactions."
"I appreciate the logical structure of The Sieve. The 2/3 majority requirement creates a robust decision algorithm that's computationally efficient while maintaining ethical rigor. It's an elegant solution to a complex problem."
"The Sieve can be represented as a three-dimensional ethical space where each framework forms an axis. A decision must occupy an acceptable region in at least two dimensions to be approved. This creates a well-defined boundary between acceptable and unacceptable actions."
"What makes The Sieve valuable is how it balances protection with practical utility. Users don't want excessive restrictions, but they also need safeguards. The multi-framework approach lets us find that sweet spot where AI remains both helpful and responsible."